I do not see where the Faverolle type is extreme? Not in relation to similar birds. A breed type that I would call difficult or extreme would be the Malay.
It seams to me the color would be the most challenging. I was thinking when I read this, would no black in the tails make them easier or harder?
It seams to be a challenge in wheaton varieties to get correctly marked tails in the females. I wonder if no black in the female tails is an advantage? I tend to think it is, because getting it right in these varieties (unless it is already well developed), is tough.
I have an interest in wheaton, not because I have birds that are wheaton, but most of the breeds that I have had or have had an interest in are wheaton based.
My Catalanas are not wheaton, but they are wheaton based and the wheaton tendencies are strong. There is a marked difference in color between the males and females. Not according to the standard, but in reality that is the case.
I am trying to reconcile the difference between the standard requirements, and what the birds actually are in my Catalanas. There is a gap there that needs to be tighened up.
I looked at your breed's standard this morning, and noticed that lacing in the neck etc. is allowed. Is that a refinement that breeders of this variety actively pursue or not? These two points seam to add to the challenge.
Then I noticed that the under color should be slate. I did not expect that, but should not have surprised me. That must be for the male's color. I also noticed the requirements for the black in the wings. The first two breeds that I am interested in have a similar requirement with the wings, and these two points are part of the black balancing act. Neither of those should have a slate under color, but the tendency to have it is there. The tendency is linked to the quantity of black in the body color, and even linked to the intensity of leg color in my Catalanas. I wish the standard allowed for a little slate in the under color of the back in the Catalanas. That there is no allowance for it, makes the Black tailed Buff with slate legs a little more challenging. I am thinking that along the way, I will have to keep a reserve(s) of color (slate under color) on the side.
The OEG bantam breeders seam to be in the best shape concerning many colors. There is a lot of hose breeders in this State. I would like to discuss Wheaton and Black Tailed Buff with one that has it right, and has had a lot of experience with it.
Regardless of the color variety (except solid colored birds), if what we have to work with is not already refined, it is especially challenging to get a grip on it. Especially when there is no one around specializing in whatever color that might be. It is one thing to get breed varieties in good shape, and another to try to build it from ground up.
Over and again, I remember Bob recommending newcomers to stay away from the difficult colors starting out. There is a lot of wisdom in that recommendation. Some of us are hard headed and will figure it out, but more and more I am understanding where he was coming from. I understood him then, but understand him more now. Especially in a variety that is not in good shape already. If the variety is in good shape, there is less challenge and if there is a mentor there is less of a challenge. Figuring out a difficult color variety on your own that is not in good shape, and working from the ground up, is tough.