That is how I tend to see it. The organization did not breed the poor performers, the breeders did. It seams that dog breeds are hurt more by becoming popular than a lot of animals. Vey few people use their dogs for the things that they were originally bred.Our Aussie is from the large end of the size spectrum. She looks & sounds like a bear when arroused. I count on her giving an intruder pause [human or animal] while I grab a weapon. Just added a 17 HMR to the arsenal-should be able to solve any Coyote problems with that.
There are 2 sides to every coin & the AKC, like the APA, is responsible for the survival of many breeds. However, I do agree that Colies wefre ruined by the show ring. My Grandfather told me of Collies he owned long ago that were superb cattle dogs. Also,s a former sheep farmer I prefer the working Border Collie o the show version but must admit the show doga are beautiful.
I am a GSD fan. Always have been and always will be. I have a couple. I always liked the idea of breeding them, but always figured that was best left to those that trained them to be what they are. They could better evaluate the performers, and make better breeding choices. If I was to try it, I would be little more than a backyard propagator. There is plenty of those. Sure I could pick those that looked the part, but I think there is more to a good GSD than that. I will stick with enjoying having one or two around, and admiring the breed in general.