Need some expert opinions! Rhode Island Whites were a breed I was researching along with the light brahmas. Getting the feeling RIW's are a bit too far gone for what we are able to do. Even the thread here on them doesn't have a lot of activity.
Am I correct in feeling I should remove them from my potential breeds list?
The fact that you are entertaining the idea of dropping them is your answer.
If you take on a "real challenge" (translation - Frustrating Mission, nearly impossible) you must be so enthralled and fixated on the breed that when all your hard work seems to offer little reward, you don't give up. If the idea of only infinitesimal progress, over the course of several generations, will not put you off, you can tackle an extremely neglected breed. Be warned, though, most poultry people/breeders (not all, but many) will be hesitant to invest time in what they see as a hopeless cause (a novice they perceive has bitten off too much, not the breed) and most of your acquired knowledge will be through listening, researching, and keeping quiet about what you are doing.
I had one of these on my list. I kept coming back to them even though I was told over and over that it was too far gone to fool with. I became fixated on it and the problems became evident immediately. I am two years into this project and just now starting to select for breeding from some birds that are well below where I thought I would be starting.
This thread has been very helpful, in an indirect way. I read it daily. I have often started writing a post to get advice, realized that I didn't have enough information to even formulate a logical question, and ended up finding what I needed while researching how to ask what I wanted to know.
YellowHouseFarm invested some of his valuable time in me at the Ohio Nationals, and for his help, I am unbelievably grateful. I think about what he shared with me every time I look at my birds. One day, I hope to be able to hand him one of my birds that, while likely not impressive in and of itself, will cause him to say, "Wow, they've come a long way." That is a long term goal.
Thank you, Joseph, you rock. Serica, choose the ones that make your toes curl...........