Quote:
You bet! This is verbatim from a 1950's Betty Crocker Cookbook that belonged to my mom. She made this every summer. I added my notes at the end.
Best Tomato Catsup
1-1/2 teaspoons whole cloves
1-1/2 teaspoons broken stick cinnamon
1 teaspoon celery seed
1 cup white vinegar
8 pounds ripe tomatoes (about 25 medium tomatoes)
1 tablespoon chopped onion
1/4 teaspoon red pepper
1 cup sugar
4 teaspoons salt
Measure spices into saucepan. Add vinegar. Cover. Heat to a boil. Remove from heat; let stand while you prepare the tomato mixture. (Spices steep in vinegar- just like tea. It's this separate brewing for spicy flavor that keeps catsup a rich red color.)
Peel tomatoes. Place in kettle; mash. Add onion and red pepper. Heat to a boil; cook 15 minutes, stirring occasionally.
Put tomatoes through a food mill or a coarse sieve. Add sugar. Heat to a boil; then simmer briskly. Cook til you have only half the amount you began with (Measure amount now with a ruler so you won't have to guess later. When mixture
looks as if it has cooked down to half, check your guess with ruler.) It will take 45 to 60 minutes.
Strain vinegar and spice directly into tomato mixture. Discard spices; add salt. Simmer to consistency you like for catsup. Stir frequently. Fill hot sterilized pint jars; seal; label. Makes 2 pints.
My notes
After I put the tomatoes through the food mill for a bit, I dump it into the food processor and pulse it 2 or 3 times to moosh up the tomato meat that is left. I rinse the seeds from the food mill. Then I put it through the food mill again. After it is done cooking down and right before I process it, I run it though the food processor again. It makes it smoother. I use a water bath to process for 15 minutes.
I usually do a double or triple batch, depending on how many tomatoes I have ripe at any one time. It is a lot of work for 2 measly pints.
It sure is good. Better than anything from the store. We have made it with yellow tomatoes. Not as acidic, but just wasn't "right". Catsup should be red after all. LOL.
We have used this as a base for BBQ sauce too. We replace the sugar with Karo and add fresh garlic or elephant garlic, smoke flavor and other spices to taste. Once we made a cherry garlic BBQ sauce that was heavenly!
Have fun!