my 5 year old loves clinton anderson - that's where she taught herself on his youtube video's on training horses. LOLWhat have you tried? Some find a whip too much pressure at first; they may expend huge amounts of energy just trying to get away from it and not pay any real attention to you (reacting rather than thinking). You can take Clinton Anderson's approach of letting them run until they are so tired they are ready to listen, but I'd rather not go there if I don't have to. I prefer to just use a long (8 ft) lead rope. Starting with just "walk" and "whoa" on the lead, I get one walking, then pay out the rope and start pushing them forward by allowing myself to drop back behind the drive line (the shoulder) and flip or spin the end of the rope toward the haunches if they don't keep moving. I do use one of C.A's sticks, but without the lash - I use it to tap when working on things like yielding. I've done it enough, I mostly don't need it; just pointing at the relevant body part is enough pressure to get them to move most of the time.