How many roosters?

This will be a crap shoot. It may work as some have said, and it may be a disaster, with things fighting to a bloody death. Roosters are a crap shoot, some turn out nice, some turn into demons. The friendliest chicks often become the worst nightmares. Chickens are not like puppies, where if people are good to them, and they are raised together, they all get along.

I would not attempt your plan. There is a high chance that your hens will be badly beat up. The flock will be in a pretty high state of tension most of the time. At adolescents, it will be very rough.

If you do try and do this you need:
* a separate pen set up and ready to go, so that you can immediately separate birds.
* a long handled fishing net, so as to be able to capture a fighting bird and separate them

Any time you keep roosters, in my opinion, you need a sharp knife, so as to remove a bird that is not working out in the flock. A bachelor pad would also work, but needs to be a great distance from the ladies. Roosters have been known to fight themselves bloody through a fence trying to get at the other roosters.

As for adding birds, generally the coop /run are already built. MEASURE that to determine if you can add birds. Do not fall into the trap of thinking that if you free range you can have more birds. The size of the coop determines that, and during the long nights of winter, that is where they are, in the coop.

A lot depends on what you mean by a backyard chicken flock. If you have your chickens in a barn, with huge amount of space, and you truly have room for 30-40 head of hens, this will probably work, although even then, sometimes it won't. But if you have a dozen birds in the back yard, this is more than likely NOT going to work well.

You may worry what the nieces will think, but seeing animals torn apart, or with gapping holes is not sweet either.

I have had chickens for years, I have had a father/son set of roosters that did not work out too badly... until I did reduce them, was rather amazed at the difference in tension in the flock, when I replace those two with a single rooster.

This will most likely be hardest on your hens.

Mrs K
 
I currently have 8 roosters with 20 hens. I have no issues (yet) they were all from the same hatch so have been together since day one. They are 9 months old now. Their still getting along but watching closely.

I also know that breed just as well as age can determine if more than one rooster can get along. I have Orust and they seem to be very docile.
 
Wow, thanks everyone for all your advice! Sooo much expertise here on Backyard Chickens!! I'm definitely glad I posted my question.

So, I guess the general consensus is that although it can and does work for some, it's a risky venture. I'm thinking at the moment that we'll take our chances and keep Corky, the boy our broody is raising, but rehome Stormy, my sister's cockerel. I'm hoping it'll be ok - the coop is quite big, and contains lots of shrubs and tussocks, which allows the chooks to get space from each other. Most (almost all) of the time they free range over about 2 acres, but as has been pointed out, it's the times they are locked in the coop that matters. We have a spare coop/aviary we can separate them into if required, and although it wouldn't be a long term option (it's rather small), it will allow us to keep the birds safely separated if there is an issue. We'll just need to keep a close eye on them, particularly when spring hits, I'd imagine (currently summer here in Australia)!

Mrs K, you make a good point about the impact on the hens. I hadn't considered that - I was too busy worrying about the potential for the boys to injure (or worse) each other. The good news is that the hens have access to the yard around the house via a gap under the fence whereas the rooster can't fit through, so the girls have the option of getting away from the rooster(s) if hounded. Mind you, at least with the existing rooster, the hens don't tolerate too much funny business from him. He's a lovely, gentle rooster who takes good care of his ladies, but they walk all over him! ;-)

Anyway, as several of you have suggested, I've now let the broody and her two chicks out to free range with the other birds and she's keeping a close eye on them. The rooster isn't allowed too close to the chicks apparently!

Oh, if there is an issue as Corky heads into adolescence, has anyone ever tried Suprelorin implants? We have a couple of our hens on them due to tumours in their reproductive tracts (and one is looking quite male!). Apparently it can effectively chemically castrate roosters, though is often not successful. Perhaps that would also reduce aggression among males if tension does arise between the boys? Just a thought that suddenly came to me...

Thanks again for all of your thoughtful suggestions and for sharing your experiences!
 
Oh, if there is an issue as Corky heads into adolescence, has anyone ever tried Suprelorin implants? We have a couple of our hens on them due to tumours in their reproductive tracts (and one is looking quite male!). Apparently it can effectively chemically castrate roosters, though is often not successful. Perhaps that would also reduce aggression among males if tension does arise between the boys? Just a thought that suddenly came to me...

Thanks again for all of your thoughtful suggestions and for sharing your experiences!
This is not something I can offer an opinion on. My chickens are not pets, so hens with tumors would be culled, and all extra cockerels get relocated to the freezer or jars in the pantry.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom