You're right, Carolyn...I wish I could find a study in which they used several different groups fed at various inclusion rates. I've found such studies for nearly everything but DE. Everything I've seen for DE so far has been done with a test group at 2% and a control group with zero.
268P Effect of diatomaceous earth on internal parasites of freerange,
organic laying hens. D. C. Bennett*, Y.-J. Rhee, A. Yee, and K.
M. Cheng, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Parasitic infections can have a significant detrimental impact on freerange
poultry production, but organic farming regulations do not allow
the routine use of pesticides to control parasitism. Therefore, there is
a need for an effective and safe method of treatment. One proposed
treatment is the use of diatomaceous earth (DE). The purpose of this
study, therefore, is to evaluate the effects of DE on internal parasites of
free-range organic layer hens. Day old pullets of two commercial egg
laying strains (Bovan brown, Lohmann brown) were reared indoors
until 11 weeks of age, and then transferred to hen-houses with access to
outdoor range. Birds were initially fed a certified organic grower mash,
which was replaced with a certified organic layer mash at 18 weeks
of age. Starting at 16 weeks of age, half the hens of each line began
receiving these diets supplemented with 2 % diatomaceous earth. Body
mass, and egg production and quality were monitored throughout the
experiment. Parasitic load was assessed by bi-weekly fecal egg counts
(FEC) performed on 40 individual hens (10 hens/diet/strain) at bi-weekly
intervals between 16 and 28 weeks of age. These hens were sacrificed
between 33 and 38 weeks of age, and their trachea and gastrointestinal
tract examined for the presence of helminthic parasites.
DE had no effect
on the number of hens infected, FEC, or worm burdens. However, body
mass and egg production were greater in hens consuming the DE diets.
These hens also laid larger eggs with thicker shells. The results of this
study suggest that there is no evidence that DE is an effective treatment
to control gastrointestinal parasitic infections of free-range laying hens.
However, DE as a feed ingredient may maintain body mass, increase
egg production and improve egg quality in free range laying hens fed
an organic diet.
edit: I have not yet found any study in which they've used a group on 5%. Anyone? Bueller?