I live in Central Ohio. I am rural but I run a Frontier natural products co-op out of my home that serves a lot of Columbus and Delaware folks(nearby cities). A friend of mine sells her organic broilers and eggs through my co-op. She sells her eggs for $3.50 a dozen. There is more demand than supply. Organic eggs here go for $3.50-4.50 a dozen at Whole Foods. I sell my organic eggs to folks at church and to friends for $3.25 a dozen, $3.00 if they supply an egg carton.
The farmer who mills our feed keeps raising prices so I am sure my friend and I will have to raise our prices this spring/summer. I am not trying to make a profit as she is, I just want to cover feed costs and the cost of gas from driving to get the feed!
Non-organic brown eggs sold from local farms advertising by a sign near the road go for about 2-2.50 a dozen around here.