by your math I should only have 2.6 chicken in my 4x10 run and 3.2 chickens in my4x4 coop. ahhh I have four ladies. So If I rehome 2 of my chickens they should be fine. I can not give them any more space than that other than a few hours a day in the yard which is kinda small. i wish i would have seen this thread before doing my chicken math using the BYC
And here is where the real harm of the "more is better" mentality comes in. You were perfectly happy, your chickens were destined for a happy, easy life, but now you see someone on the internet up the ante from 4 to 5 square feet so suddenly, you are a horrible chicken slum lord and you must give away your two chickens so that they don't have to be subjected to your evil ways. Only now, instead of being happy in your backyard paradise, they are going to go to some unknown place and likely end up upside down in a chicken cone at 11 months of age wondering where life went wrong.
Next year, some one is going to say, "Eight! Eight square feet per bird! I used to do five square feet per bird, but then I had to clean out the bedding every two weeks! I did not like that because my chickens were crowded! One even filed a lawsuit in state court. I now follow the eight square feet per bird rule in the coop and ten acres per bird outside the coop. My 4,000 sq ft home...I mean coop...houses 2 chickens, and they have room to run and play and watch HD tv. The other day one even kicked me out of the bathtub and filled it with sand! It was so happy!"
So now your 16 square foot coop is only good enough for 1 chicken. "Sorry, Henny, you've gotta go. You are not happy here, and Betsy Hen needs the extra room to...to...I don't know what for, but she needs it says the internets! Now come back here! This is for your own good!"
Of course then someone will say "Twenty! Twenty square feet per bird like in the olden days when cave men roamed the Earth and kept scaly green chickens that laid purple eggs!" And then you will give away your one remaining chicken because your coop is too small to hold even a single chicken.
I know a lot of people who keep chickens. None of them have 4 square feet per bird. Most have 3 or less. Their chickens have been healthy and happy for years. No disease, no cannibalism, no state law suits.
Yes, more is better. A chicken will be happier with 5 square feet than 4. It will be happier still with 6, 9, or 50. But if you're a good owner, take good care of them, they can be happy in almost any reasonable circumstance. There is a local farmer here with about 12 chickens. They live in 3 or 4 small things that look like rabit hutches, about 2'x 1.5' open mesh front boxes. They free range most of the day and huddle in the hutch things at night, 3 or 4 per hutch. I bet they're a hell of a lot happier than any chickens that have 10 sq ft per bird in a coop and 15 in a run. And I bet your chickens will be happier still, because you sound like a person who cares about animals.
The guy who got me into chickens has a 4x3 coop and a 10x12 run and has 5 full size hens and one bantam. They have been there over a year and they are perfectly happy and healthy. No pecking, no disease, no signs of unhappiness at all. That's a 12 square foot coop with 6 happy chickens in a space that the 4sqft rule says should only house 3 chickens, and the 5sqft rule, 2 chickens.
Please don't give away your chickens because someone gave you a number and some horror stories on the internet.