If the fermented feed works for you, by all means use it!
Alternatively, will your birds eat feed that has simply been moistened by water? Of course you want to feed them only what they can eat within an hour or two. So you would need to meal-feed them if you try this.
Feeders that prevent raking of feed out also help. I built mine out of 5 gallon buckets and it's done the trick. Every flock is different, though, of course! If yours do well on the Fermented Feed, proceed, just use care and watch for signs of problems when the weather does not cooperate.
That's just it, I am unsure if the FF is working ok. It was, up until a week or so ago. I'm not even sure if it's the feed, but that was my first guess, especially after reading your thread and links. Thanks again by the way. I do use some wet feed in the winter, with some eggs and a tad of yogurt or buttermilk off and on also. but as you said, only what they will eat in an hour. I wouldn't dare do that in the warmer weather, especially since I am questioning the FF that is supposed to grow good bacteria and "eat" the bad. I am not new to chickens, just the FF and a tad nervous, since I am working my way back into chickens and standard breeds only and can't afford to lose any as they are what I have to work with. As Ralf Sturgeon said, "start with what you have" or something like that. That is where I am at, working with what I have. I resisted the FF until the feed loss was so large I really had to try something different. Do you have a picture of the feeder you use? I would definitely be interested in trying that. I did give the little pullet in the house with an eye infection some dry feed and she did eat a little.
I find it somewhat unlikely that you are causing harm due to your flora, unless you are spitting into the feed or something else equally rude. It's not impossible but unlikely.
Well that's good to know, that it is less likely!
Honestly, with as wet as it has been, it could have been anything outdoors. It would be my first guess, if that is indeed what you are dealing with. When mine had clostridium, it was also an exceptionally wet time for us!
Exceptionally wet weather + lower ranking or poorly chicken = more prone to infection. Just my observation. Some may disagree.
If your poor rooster is a lower status, he may also have a slightly weakened immune system just from mild long-term stress. This is not your fault, just, a fact of life for some of the birds that are lower status. My Coho, the one that had the confirmed clostridium infection, has always been the most prone to minor illness, by far, out of my flock. She is also the lowest ranked chicken and is very dramatic if the other chickens even so much as look at her wrong. She is sickly at least once a year, is prone to infections such as bumblefoot, and it would not be a stretch to say that in her case, rank and immune system seem to go hand in hand. This is not the case for everyone's flock, by any means, but it is something that I have seen in mine and in a few other people's as well. We just give her extra love (she's very snuggly) and check on her daily, as she is even more disturbed by being away from the flock than she is by being pushed around a little, so in the end we figure that her minor stresses are worth her quality of life with the flock. If they were being mean to her that would be a different matter, but it is just minor pushing around that a flock of chickens will do.
See that is why I was leaning towards that as the reason. Wet weather, cocci and worms plus the treatments, he is definitely the low man on the totem pole and you used a VERY good word, he is very dramatic, as are all the Dominique's but he is even more so. I actually named him Alvin as a chick as he was very vocal and scared of his own shadow. I was having a hard time explaining and you nailed it with dramatic!!! What really had me sit up and pay attention was the poop smell. It is noticeably different. I personally wouldn't call it sweet, but it is not a truly bad odor, just not normal at all for chickens. I'm going to pick up the Baytril as soon as I can get some, and am giving him eggs and buttermilk, which the others steal from us but he does get quite a bit of it in him, for now until then. Thank you so much for ALL your info and if you do have picture of that feeder, I would greatly appreciate it. I didn't know they made them or is this a DIY feeder? That I can do also. I only went to FF because of the feed savings. I did notice, until recently, that their poop was MUCH better, but was wondering how it was going to work in the winter. We had -38F last winter and a frozen comb on the hatchery Rooster that the bear got. It got 4 of the hatchery hen's also. To be honest, they were/are, my test birds. I bought them to see if I could still do this chicken thing, test the viability of the land, and test for predation. All I have learned from them has been valuable, as I knew that we had cocci here, so treated the young un's until after their feet where on the ground.
The more I think about the FF and my plants...I'm wondering if the darn mushroom spores are a part of this also. Not so sure FF is for me either to be honest. It makes me nervous and adds, for me, a ton more work! Thanks again for all your help!!!