digitS' :
I'm just talking thru my hat here, so feel free to ignore me . . .
It seems to me that chickens have very similar nutritional needs as humans. But, let's leave aside the idea of setting another place at the kitchen table for them, just for a minute.
We humans seem to have some fairly serious dietary problems when left to grab whatever interests us. I mean, take a look at that recent report from the military that 27% of our young people are too fat to be admitted into military service!
We aren't expecting our hens to go to boot camp but most of us do expect some eggs from them. A poor quality diet, even if it is one selected by the hens, is bound to interfere with hoped-for egg production.
Every leftover from the kitchen?? I think that isn't going to measure up to an optimum diet or anywhere close to it. Leftovers in our house are the cheap, high-calorie stuff. It probably isn't much more nutritious than a paper feed bag . . .
The feed industry is certainly efficient. That's how they make their money -- using "stuff" that would probably be thrown away, otherwise. Still, there are certain standards that the government requires of their products. And, there is a commitment that they print onto the feed bag label for them to live up to. After all, there are folks with livestock who count on that feed providing what is needed.
And, I'm not quite ready to set another place at the table for the chickens.
Steve
I would agree with you a little.
We are talking about treats.. not a regular diet of table scraps and whatever..
I'm just talking thru my hat here, so feel free to ignore me . . .

It seems to me that chickens have very similar nutritional needs as humans. But, let's leave aside the idea of setting another place at the kitchen table for them, just for a minute.
We humans seem to have some fairly serious dietary problems when left to grab whatever interests us. I mean, take a look at that recent report from the military that 27% of our young people are too fat to be admitted into military service!
We aren't expecting our hens to go to boot camp but most of us do expect some eggs from them. A poor quality diet, even if it is one selected by the hens, is bound to interfere with hoped-for egg production.
Every leftover from the kitchen?? I think that isn't going to measure up to an optimum diet or anywhere close to it. Leftovers in our house are the cheap, high-calorie stuff. It probably isn't much more nutritious than a paper feed bag . . .
The feed industry is certainly efficient. That's how they make their money -- using "stuff" that would probably be thrown away, otherwise. Still, there are certain standards that the government requires of their products. And, there is a commitment that they print onto the feed bag label for them to live up to. After all, there are folks with livestock who count on that feed providing what is needed.
And, I'm not quite ready to set another place at the table for the chickens.
Steve

I would agree with you a little.
We are talking about treats.. not a regular diet of table scraps and whatever..