if a cow's dying in a field--(right/wrong question from non-cow owner)

Quote:
We carry liability insurance just in case any of ours would get out and get hit. I don't think a history of your animals not getting out will keep someone from suing you.
 
Quote:
I'm in NY. As far as I know, I've not heard that anyone actually hit any of the cows. Neighbors and the sheriff both stated in the articles I read that it was "a matter of time". I am pretty sure we have the same law here, I believe it applies to domestic animals of all types, not just livestock (I swear I recall a lawsuit from someone seeking damages in a car/large dog accident). From what we gathered from the woman we spoke to, the owner is a bit on the "odd" side, to be nice, and I am pretty sure there's not much that someone could get from him. And from what we saw of the house and the rusting remains of farm equipment/abandoned cars, they'd be waiting a while for financial restituion. Honestly, from what I saw of the cows too-they weren't pictures of bovine beauty. I imagine just a smigen above "cruelty to animals' charges in care.
 
downtime I don't know what the laws say in your state, but out here the law states that if your animals get out on a public road and are hit by a vehicle the owner is liable for damages. Especially if they have a history of their animals getting out.
Now if your animals get out and there is no history of them getting out and you maintain your fences you are not liable.

I'm in Ohio and State Law is that if livestock is reasonably contained that if they do get into traffic and are hit that the livestock owner is not responsible for damage. I don't have the exact paragraph but that is what it boils down to.
Having said that....my pastures were newly fenced with standards way above the law and way above what is considered the norm around here. Deer jumped the fence and got into the pasture our mini mare spooked and ran through the fence. Within minutes she was on a main highway and was struck and killed by a car.
Our insurance company came out as did the other people's and took pictures of the fencing. The court ruled against us and our homeowners liability covered it. I still don't understand how the ruling went against us, but we didn't pursue it because our insurance covered it.​
 
Quote:
Katy, have you ever used whiskey to get a downed cow up? Ed

Nope, can't say that I have!

My father didn't drink, but on occasion he would stop by the "green front store" and pick up a pint of cheap whiskey. This would be when a cow was down (usually after calving) and wouldn't/couldn't get up. He would give her a couple of days and if she hadn't gotten up he'd open her mouth, pour the pint down her throat, and stand back. Usually within several minutes the cow would be staggering to her feet. If a cow didn't get up shortly after swallowing the whiskey it usually never got up. I recall seeing him do this 2-3 times though he may have done it more times than that. That's been a lifetime ago now since I saw him do it...probably 35-40 years ago.

Just thought I'd mention it...
Ed
 
A cow down for days should have been seen and shot by the owner if nothing else. There aren't too many places, thankfully, that are so insane that a farmer can't put down livestock intended for food. Where we live I sometimes help animal control document cases. Unfortunately what you saw is not uncommon. Most notable case here lately was a man who just let a herd starve because he didn't have the money for feed and the graze ran out, sixteen had died, another 14 dying, he just ignored them as his fields filled with dead cattle. But one cow, or two or four, not even particularly noteworthy as a case goes. Of course they're also ignoring the livestock dogs, who are also not being fed but who live awhile longer on the dying livestock. Unless the moron has penned them up because they've been getting out, looking for food and drawing attention to the place. The record for penned and dying great pyrenees this year so far was 24. I really would rather not see that number topped.

Some folks keep livestock well and reasonably and provide a humane end instead of a vet, and that's okay. What the OP saw, Letting it die for days downed and suffering in it's own s--- pile is not right but it's done all the time. Some people care. Some don't. Laws don't make anyone care. You care, or you don't. Your're responsible within your means, or you aren't. Can't feed it, sell it or kill it humanely. But a slow death by starvation and disease... just because someone can't be bothered... In my opinion it's wrong, but opinions are exactly like .......holes, everyone has one and no one like's anyone else's.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom