glad I saw this post today! My broody did not want to move to her own apartment in the corner of the barn.What I have been doing is putting a piece of chicken wire just over the nest box the broody decides to choose and that's where she gets to stay. I let them out in the evening when I get home from work anytime before that (tried on the weekends) they refuse to come out. When I let them out they are only out for about 10 mins, if that, so I usually just do what chores I can and come back....sometimes they pick the wrong nest again but if you come back after a few minutes, its easy enough to put them on the right one. So its working rather well actually!