jersey giant or black orpington?

[froggyphore]

i have 6 chicks that were sold to me as jersey giants. i looked up this guide https://meyerhatchery.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/360009871752-Day-Old-Chick-Identification and two of them have the same spots as black orpingtons. all six have similar legs as well with black legs & yellow toes. they're all the same size. was i sold the wrong breed or do JG & BO chicks sometimes look similar?

 

[Mamatomany123]

Do you have pictures? Include the feet and legs.

 

[froggyphore]

Do you have pictures? Include the feet and legs.

are these okay? they were being wiggly but i'm taking them to my greenhouse for a little while tomorrow so i can take some better ones then if needed.

the one with a white beak tip has a spot on her chest and the other one has a light grey chest. their feet are a yellow orange color, the lighting in the last pic makes them look pink. thank you for your help

 

[Acre4Me]

pics please under regular white light. Take pic from the side while they are standing. Try to get pic of legs and flesh between the toes (if yellow feet bottoms can likely see some yellow there).

 

[Acre4Me]

can we see the feet bottoms under regular light? Cant tell color of feet bottoms in these pics.

 

[Acre4Me]

Here's an example of different feet color:

BA have more pink/flesh color feet bottoms.

BJG have yellow feet bottoms

 

[froggyphore]

Here's an example of different feet color:

BA have more pink/flesh color feet bottoms.
View attachment 2126008


BJG have yellow feet bottoms
View attachment 2126009

View attachment 2126015View attachment 2126016

thank you so much! they definitely have a bright yellow tone to their feet like the JGs. i can't post any white-light photos from indoors as all my lamps are red-tone grow lights for my house plants, but i'm taking them out to explore my greenhouse tomorrow so i can get some better photos in there

 

[froggyphore]

Here's an example of different feet color:

BA have more pink/flesh color feet bottoms.
View attachment 2126008


BJG have yellow feet bottoms
View attachment 2126009

View attachment 2126015View attachment 2126016

still a bit too wiggly for perfect photos, but i did manage to get these thank you for your help

 

[birdsrfun]

Looking at the photos from @Acre4Me, I’d say yours look like BJG.

 

[Acre4Me]

They look like BJG with those yellow feet bottoms.