Quote:
I too agree that the stand offish ones make the best flock protectors. One of my brahmas is very stand offish to the point we had to chase him for a good 20 minutes. He however is a great flock protector, I was not an eye witness but did hear of him jumping into a hawk who was trying to scoop up a helpless leghorn hen. My giants are the same way. Whenever there is a threat, their eyes are to the sky. The dominent roo of the flock that leads the flock out and is last to go in is a Giant, and they are also the furtherest along at crowing. All of the above birds are scittish.
My buff orpingtons and rhode island reds are loving birds, but they often opt to retreat instead of stand up in the face of danger: Not exactly flock protector material. So from experience, I can definitely agree with your theory.
vortec