Not even close. As soon as you submerge a animal whose instinct is to NEVER be underwater, it starts to panic frantically, and then it stays in that panic until it drowns. Have you ever been in a pool of water and stayed under to long?drowning is fast, certainly as fast as shooting, at least they way shooting goes sometimes, as in several shots, animal moves around violently. I trapped squirrels in my attack one time and called around to the authorities to see what I should do with them and they said it was illegal to release them and specifically told me to get a bucket, fill it with water and submerse the trap in it for 5 minutes, rinse and repeat.
You know why you are underwater and it WILL make you start to panic.
Otherwise I caught a coon in a trap, it was scared but not panicked. To drown is aweful.
----
My dad used a chicken to hatch some ducklings once. Those ducklings jumped in his pond and start swimming around, and the momma chicken freaked out. She knew they should not be on top of the water. That animal knows what water is, and is scared to be in it.