King County, Washington!

I would respectfully challenge that "you will not get any better quality chicks from other random feed stores". True the genetics will not be any better as the chicks are coming from hatchery stock, however I strongly believe it is still important as to how those chicks are handled, housed, etc. prior to sale. And that can be the difference between a random feed store and knowing the entity that you're buying chicks from.

Based on my own personal experience, I originally purchased chicks from a feed store in Monroe. The store had a very lazy approach to their chick conditions, setup, and so on. Obvious older chicks were kept with day old chicks and several were not looking healthy. My wife and I tried our best to pick two of the "better" looking chicks, but when we got them home it took nearly a week of obsessive nurturing to get them healthy enough to mix with our other two baby chicks (purchased from the Issaquah Grange Supply that same day, which is another fine store to buy chicks from). Honestly that first night we figured they were doomed and were already looking at the chick delivery schedule at Grange Supply for the next weekend's shipment.

It is not that these chicks from the feed store were better/worse than from Baxter Barn. In fact, the hens from these original sick chicks are measurably better layers than my hens that originated from the Issaquah Grange. My point is you can set yourself up for better success right at the start by purchasing chicks that you can be more confident are healthy and well cared for prior to sale. How many times have people purchased feed store chicks and have a couple of them die?

Having said all that, I'm 3 years into my (declining production) hens and am starting to replace them. I purchased more chicks from Baxter Barn this weekend. I'll even say that Cory, the proprietor of Baxter Barn, is not warm and fuzzy and always easy person to do business with. But I trust the source of my chicks and have had 100% survival rates from here.

Just my two cents and far from expert advise, just based on my personal experience.
 
I think you missed my whole point. Baxter Barn has HATCHERY chicks just like all the feed stores. They are the same birds, just the feed store prices are cheaper than Baxter Barn. BB might have more breeds just because they have more space to house them all.

Private breeders take care of their chicks and chickens because their reputation depends on having healthy animals and happy customers. With feed stores, this is not always the case, much like what you saw happen at the Monroe store. They will still have customers coming in even if they sell sick and/or low quality birds. Maybe because they are a big chain with a famous name, or perhaps have a fancy location near the mall.
 
I think you missed my whole point.  Baxter Barn has HATCHERY chicks just like all the feed stores.  They are the same birds, just the feed store prices are cheaper than Baxter Barn.  BB might have more breeds just because they have more space to house them all.  

Private breeders take care of their chicks and chickens because their reputation depends on having healthy animals and happy customers.  With feed stores, this is not always the case, much like what you saw happen at the Monroe store.  They will still have customers coming in even if they sell sick and/or low quality birds.  Maybe because they are a big chain with a famous name, or perhaps have a fancy location near the mall.  


Ah ok. That makes a lot of sense cause so far I'm not impressed by these chicks. I'll have to find a breeder next.. But I'm mostly stuck with what I got now. I don't have room for anymore chicks ;0

Going through breeders seems confusing though, I want a variety, and finding someone close seems difficult...
 
I would respectfully challenge that "you will not get any better quality chicks from other random feed stores". True the genetics will not be any better as the chicks are coming from hatchery stock, however I strongly believe it is still important as to how those chicks are handled, housed, etc. prior to sale. And that can be the difference between a random feed store and knowing the entity that you're buying chicks from.

Based on my own personal experience, I originally purchased chicks from a feed store in Monroe. The store had a very lazy approach to their chick conditions, setup, and so on. Obvious older chicks were kept with day old chicks and several were not looking healthy. My wife and I tried our best to pick two of the "better" looking chicks, but when we got them home it took nearly a week of obsessive nurturing to get them healthy enough to mix with our other two baby chicks (purchased from the Issaquah Grange Supply that same day, which is another fine store to buy chicks from). Honestly that first night we figured they were doomed and were already looking at the chick delivery schedule at Grange Supply for the next weekend's shipment.

It is not that these chicks from the feed store were better/worse than from Baxter Barn. In fact, the hens from these original sick chicks are measurably better layers than my hens that originated from the Issaquah Grange. My point is you can set yourself up for better success right at the start by purchasing chicks that you can be more confident are healthy and well cared for prior to sale. How many times have people purchased feed store chicks and have a couple of them die?

Having said all that, I'm 3 years into my (declining production) hens and am starting to replace them. I purchased more chicks from Baxter Barn this weekend. I'll even say that Cory, the proprietor of Baxter Barn, is not warm and fuzzy and always easy person to do business with. But I trust the source of my chicks and have had 100% survival rates from here.

Just my two cents and far from expert advise, just based on my personal experience. 


Well, one of my chicks I got from Baxter Barn died several hours after getting home, and I'm currently struggling to figure out why one is hock walking and perching alone in the cold corner most of the time. I'm also wondering why 2 chicks have completely bare butts, is that part of the sexing process? Idk... Like I said I'm not impressed and should have tried harder to find a breeder... I just want happy, healthy chickens, I don't care as much about show or breed stock...
 
Hi sphinxface

Sorry to hear about a rough start to your chicks. I guess I should clarify that I am not a die hard advocate for Baxter Barn. I've gotten 6 chicks from them on 2 separate occasions and all has gone well, but that is just my personal experience. If you're having issues with chicks you just got I would give them a call and see what they'll do for you. They may even replace them. When we picked up chicks 2 weeks ago I had asked about the Salmon Favorelles and even though they had the chicks onsite they advised me against them because they were a "weak" batch and not the healthiest chicks they had available. I appreciated that.

There are of course other places that have been nice for just hatchery chicks, such as Issaquah Grange Supply and Portage Bay Grange.

Good luck!
 
I did tell them about the chick that died and they offered to replace it, but it was more as a courtesy on my part because I accidentally got too many ;P

I just imagine it must be hard to get much variety from breeders?
 
I would bet that ochochicas has a much better idea of what breeders have to offer. I believe you are correct that the variety will be much more limited as breeders are going to have a much sharper focus on a specific breed or two. I don't know what breeders are around the King/Pierce/Snohomish county area, but maybe someone else can weigh in.
 
Sorry, I have been gone for a bit. If you are in Renton you have a lot of options for where to get chicks from. There are people in King county the list chicks for sale both on BYC and also on Craigslist. There is also a facebook page with chicks and supplies for sale. I know of at least 2 people in the Puyallup area that have gorgeous healthy chicks for sale in a variety of breeds. If you need any recommendations or contact numbers, please PM me. There are also quite a few people in the Enumclaw, Auburn and Maple Valley areas that have birds for sale.

IMO, getting a chick from a private party is ALWAYS better than buying hatchery birds from a feed store or a place like Baxter Barn. I'm not saying the hatchery birds are not going to be good layers, but the birds from local people will have been treated better and will be healthier in most cases. Out of the original 8 "pullets" I got at a feed store, only 4 of them lived to be a year old (2 were cockerels and 2 died from strange illnesses before their first birthday). One quit laying all together right after she turned a year old, and one was a totally different breed that wasn't what I wanted. So out of 8 chicks, I only had 2 layers that are still laying after their second birthday. The other two are freeloading.
big_smile.png
I still love them and they are sweet birds, but I would have gotten better quality birds with more longevity if I had gone to a breeder.
 
I do regret it now, but I'm not sure what to do. I guess I could sell the ones I'm not attatched to? I also thought about eating them but I don't think I could...? Ack! And then maybe the husband likes them so IDK, stuck with em :p

On a different note, I see TONS of BYC driving around locally, but not as many people on the site, I guess they just like doing their own thing? ;P
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom