I am on the bandwagon with getting both, but if you have to choose just one, then your whole family needs to go visit and see which one fits best with your family. They are both adorable. I have two kittens almost 12 weeks old.
Hmmm. I was going to say I couldn't choose either, but...I am partial to blues. And with those white markings, she'll be easier than the other one (and both of your current cats) to see in the dark. So I guess I vote for the blue and white one if both isn't an option.
IF getting two cats would work for you right now, I would say go for it! If not, I try to never choose a pet based on looks. Whoever chooses me is the one! Of course I feel it's only fair to choose the most deserving pet when rescuing, it's a matter of life or death at the shelter. It's never easy, that's for sure. Either way, none of our animals are bad lookin'.
Quote:
When we got Gus and Woodrow, we stood in the middle of the whole litter, and the first two to climb up our legs were the winners. They are such sweet kittens!!! I hope the OP has a chance to take her family to meet them.