I like the looks of your Cull #1. I know his comb has those spikes BUT,
First, I like long wattles and his seem the longest of all yours. The SOP calls for wattles on the male as "uniform, long, well rounded, pendulous. I have noticed in mine some variation in length.
Second, his earlobes look large which is what the SOP calls for. I am looking at earlobe looking like it meets under their neck.
He is from Bill, correct? If he is, I would not mind having him, if you are up for a trade?
Just my two cents.