Lace cochin v Wyandottes

[CHICKENX2005]

I have a friend who lives near you. ( In Virginia ) and she is planning on getting some silkies soon. And the people that she might get them from live in a really cold and wet and very hot in summer place and they said their chicken are doing great. They are very hardy. And do better than most other breeds a lot of the time.

 

[NatJ]

Is there a big difference between the two breeds over all?

Cochins have single combs and feathered legs.
Wyandottes have rose combs and clean legs.
Or at least, Wyandottes are SUPPOSED to have rose combs. Sometimes they produce chicks with single combs, which only matters if you care about the comb type. If you want to enter them in a show, the comb type matters. In many other situations it does not matter.

Body shape and size should be a bit different.

I would expect Wyandottes to mature faster and lay more eggs. I would expect Cochins to mature later (bigger birds so they spend more time growing), and lay fewer eggs (fewer per week, plus a later start.)

For maturity and egg laying abilities, where you get them can make a big difference. Different sources are focused on different traits-- that could be two different hatcheries, or two different private breeders, or one of each. If you got both breeds from several sources, you might find that the earliest and latest layers, or the best and worst layers, were the same breed from different sources, with the other breed being in the middle (no, I can't predict which breed would be the outlier or the one in the middle. That is just an example of the kind of thing that can happen.)

I was leaning towards cochin as they are heavier and I may not have to tip their wing to keep them from going over the fence when free roaming. But noise level and friendliness are factors I am looking into as well.

Unfortunately, I can't help with any of those specific points (although I do see that several other people talked about them.)

 

[CHICKENX2005]

None of my cochens have ever flown over the fence or tried to but I can tell you some breeds that I own or have owned in the past that fly over the fence ALL THE TIME.

Ameraucanas

Easier Eggers

Pearl White Leghorns

Cinnamon queens ( before they got old )

And surprisingly one of my jersey giants flies out even if I clip her wing.

Roade island reds ( just a note I don't recommend ever getting a roade island red rooster ) I don't keep roade island reds anymore for many reasons. I just have my one old lady RIR left.

 

[Porkchopmama]

I've never owned adult wyandottes. I've heard mixed opinions as far as friendliness goes some say that they are so sweet and friendly and others say that they are aggressive. Usually people have told me that theirs are friendly but if you do get a aggressive one ( especially a rooster ) then it's evil. But that's just what I've been told I don't own any. But I have owned cochens and they are I my experience the friendliest of all chickens. I've never owned a aggressive one or heard of anyone who did. ( not saying that it can't happen ) but I can say that I have loved all my cochens and cochen mixes. But it's up to you. Maybe someone who has owned wyandottes can tell you more about them.

I have a blue and red Wyandotte rooster and he is very mellow at less than a year old. No flogging or attacking of any kind. I have hand feed him before as well.

 

[Dominique King]

Whatever reason I thought Wyandottes laid med or small eggs, but apparently they are the same size as the lace cochin but the birds themselves are easier to find. Is there a big difference between the two breeds over all? I was leaning towards cochin as they are heavier and I may not have to tip their wing to keep them from going over the fence when free roaming. But noise level and friendliness are factors I am looking into as well.

I have never owned either type of these chickens and wanted to ask here before I order any chicks. Most places seen out of the lace cochin and I can locally get the Wyandottes is even why I am asking now. If there isn't huge differences.. they have the look or similar look to what I'd like to get.

I own Golden Laced Wyandottes and they are very good egg layers and ad well as laying well throughout winter. They have very strong wings so you have to be careful with their wings.

Plum.

Peg.
They are very sweet birds in my opinion and are very beautiful!
I have not had any experience with
laced cochins so I can’t tell you anything about that.
But my Wyandottes lay big eggs.
So that is my statement.
Take it as you will though.