Interesting. I've always been kind to the rat snakes here, I allow them free-run over my property and not once have I regretted their presence. If you have snakes eating tree roosting chicks then it's ultimately just natural selection (which applies to predators also)
During the summer rains last year I had a ton of rats invade my property. I got a barn cat, which barely seemed to do anything. However one day a huge black rat snake showed up and that very same night I heard rats screaming and dying in the walls of my barn
In the context of my own chickens and food production, rat snakes are beneficial. They steal eggs occasionally, but I have such an abundance of those that they're welcome to them. I'd much rather feed a snake I know kills rats over a lazy cat
View attachment 3899830
If you look around on my other videos, you’ll see I’m constantly catching grey rat snakes in the process of eating chicks wherever chicks are to be found. Free-range, coops, trees, wherever. Usually the months of June and July are the worst. I think its a combination of the hot nights that lets them digest big meals at night, but also because the wild turkey poults out in the woods are too large to be preyed on by the snakes during that time of year. So the grey rat snakes shift from seeking out turkey broods to my chickens.
In nature, wild turkeys suffer ridiculously high casualties from predators. It's a wonder any of them ever survive long enough to reproduce, as they never get to a stage where they outgrow predation. Even mature gobblers are prone to being taken off the roost by great horned owls at night. When one is removed from the gene pool from that kind of predation, I don't think it's often due to weakness. It's just the random act of a predator that has a total advantage over any turkey.
I can't allow that level of natural selection to happen within my farmyard flock. If a strong wild turkey gobbler can't fight off a predator at night on the roost, there will never be a chicken that can beat any predation attempt on the roost. If there were 1,000 chickens spread out through the woods in several square miles, random predation of that sort might not wipe them out. But concentrated on my small farm yard, every taking of an otherwise healthy bird hurts the flock.
My chickens will always be livestock, no matter how tough they get. I don't think predators can be allowed to run amok. Part of a balanced flock is to keep the predators persecuted so as to keep them fearful. Once the predators' numbers are low and their attitudes timid, then they have a tendency to be more useful for taking the weaker chickens. That's the state of the birds of prey on my farm at the current time. I no longer lose healthy birds to raptors. They only pick off slow ones. I can usually identify a chicken that's about to get got a day or two before it happens. In that regard, there's a balance between my flock and the birds of prey. But that's also the result of several raptors getting selected out by my livestock guardians.
Some summers I've killed as many as a dozen grey rat snakes in June/July. This year I've only killed 2 or 3 all year. I've got their numbers in check and between myself and the dogs learning to kill them (the dogs used to ignore grey rat snakes for unknown reasons while persecuting other snakes) I believe the snakes are getting wary. The more wary they are, the less bold they are about exposing themselves and that alone severely reduces their predations.
I do believe snakes to be much smarter than we know and that they're masters of patterning their local humans. Venomous snakes especially. I often find sign of rattlesnakes weeks or months before I ever see them. When I do see them, it will usually be because I broke a pattern of my comings and goings.