Let's play a game of who laid this egg?

[Jennys fluffbutts]

I have a silkie pullet Pepper and silkie x pullet Moose , one of them just layed their first egg unfortunately I don't know who. FYI the cross is just as small as the pure silkie. Also the egg is 1.3 oz. These are the two of them and egg in question. If anyone with more experience with telling eggs apart can help that would be greatly appreciated. Thank you

 

[Chickensandhorsesforlife]

That was most likely the silkie cross. silkie eggs are normally very white and rounder

 

[Chickensandhorsesforlife]

and smaller

 

[Lady of McCamley]

My Silkie eggs looked like that....tinted and elliptical...and I have had Silkies from a number of lines. I also was always amazed at how large an egg my Silkies laid for their size.

Typically crosses will lay larger than purebreds.

 

[The Happster]

That crossbred does not look like she's laying.
My vote is on the Silkie.

 

[CrazyChicken Lady]

I’d say silkie most likely.

 

[Jennys fluffbutts]

I have a silkie and silkie x pullet, one of them just layed their first egg unfortunately I don't know who. These are the two of them and egg in question. If anyone with more experience with telling eggs apart can help that would be greatly appreciated. Thank you View attachment 2536740View attachment 2536737View attachment 2536736

That egg is fairly small, it actually looks smaller than the ones my silkies hatched from.

I have a silkie and silkie x pullet, one of them just layed their first egg unfortunately I don't know who. These are the two of them and egg in question. If anyone with more experience with telling eggs apart can help that would be greatly appreciated. Thank you View attachment 2536740View attachment 2536737View attachment 2536736

I have a silkie and silkie x pullet, one of them just layed their first egg unfortunately I don't know who. These are the two of them and egg in question. If anyone with more experience with telling eggs apart can help that would be greatly appreciated. Thank you View attachment 2536740View attachment 2536737View attachment 2536736

Also pics are from about a month ago they both turned 7mths today.

 

[aart]

https://www.backyardchickens.com/articles/who-is-laying-and-who-is-not-butt-check.73309/