I chose white, so that it doesn't absorb heat in the summer. I am in NW Missouri. They made it through the super cold spell this Feb just fine.Also, will the color affect the temp of the inside of the coop? In St. Louis it can also get up to 80 and so I do not want to bake them inside with a black tarp.
It has held up very well, just make sure you fasten it down taut. Rubbing against something when the wind is blowing will wear it quickly. We regularly get 25 mph sustained winds here.