Tnic: I'd love to go to a work shop to learn how to caponize. And that would make the process of raising meat birds much easier. But, the one roo I'm keeping now is my genetic pool for future generations of chicks on my little homestead. I know they say, don't put all of your eggs in one basket, and it's not wise to keep only one roo for breeding purposes... but given my limited space, and his penchant for crowing all day long starting at 5 AM, even that's stretching the good neighbor policy! Wouldn't it be great if we could get together as a group, and have some one come in and teach us how to caponize next spring??? If we had a workshop in the southern part of the state, it would also draw folks from NH, and Mass.
Island girl, I've also considered the benefit of training my roo to not crow. I think it could be accomplished with the benefit of a super soaker squirt gun. Of course you wouldn't want to use it in the cold months, but I think if you started early in his crowing career it would work. Especially, if you were able to pull it off without him seeing that you were the cause of it. Some folks say they are able to train their roos to verbal command re: crowing. I have my doubts there, and think that they may be blessed with roos who just aren't so much in love with hearing their own voice.
Then there's the one breeder who says he's breeding the egg song out of his flock. Choosing to not hatch eggs from the vocal layers. And he appears to be succeeding. I think that if there was a strain of birds that were bred to be quiet, there would be a lot of interest from the urban flockster.