I only got thru half of this thread and became disgusted at the posters questioning you about being threatened and defending a guy that comes to your door with a bag in hand for your rooster.
It is ridiculous for you people to say the things you say about the OP! It's getting to the point here where people don't want to post for advice because you get people coming out of the woodwork calling you a bad person and questioning you and your incident.
What do you people expect? Should she sit down and talk to her roo and explain to him that he needs to refrain from crowing until a decent hour? As if that would work.
If this man doesn't live right on top of the coop, I guarantee that the crowing is NOT waking him up at 5 am!
I have a neighbor that lives about 200 feet from my house and she doesn't hear my roo crowing at 5 am, which he does every morning.
Bottom line, she is allowed roos where she lives.
This man comes to her door with another man with a bag in hand for her roo.
To me that is a threat and would be treated as such!
If the same situation happened to me I would have given the man an earfull of not so choice words and told him if he set foot on my property again, he would be carried off, with his stupid bag!!
Keep a record of what happened that day, make a report, and if your birds suddenly start to die off for no apparent reason, have a necropsy done and file charges on the SOB!
Ignore the foolsih posters who are giving you a hard time and bashing you!