Quote:
Rooster Cruiser The Marans Standard demands that the birds egg color be a 4 or better to even qualify as a member of the breed. You could have a hen that is perfect according to the standard in all other ways but if she doesn't lay a 4 on the color chart she isn't even a Marans! It defines the Marans breed also. In an age where dual purpose birds have fallen out of favor a bird that is as heavy, slow maturing, and consumptive as the Marans without having a high lay rate would be considered usless. Why would someone want to own a bird with nothing "speacial" about it. I would get orphingtons if the Marans didn't lay dark eggs they are just as big and beautiful and lay twice the eggs! The Marans breed is defined by the dark eggs and without them I doubt they would ever have gained any amount of popularity. For good Marans breeder its a constant balance between type and egg color and its very difficult to reach. Many irrisponisble or inexperianced breeders have bred only for egg color and the type and color has fallen apart in there birds. Marans breeding is basically an art form. The inexperianced breeders are what caused the Marans to not be accepted there first go around. Anyway exceptance for any breed or new color varitie is a very long and time consuming process.
Yes I am close to giving up on the breed for many of those reasons. I have birds from a very prominent knowledgable breeder who has been very helpful, but frankly they are poor layers, type is not great, I think the breed in general has the worst combs I have seen and some eggs are dark and many not very dark at all. I am so tempted to go a different route.
I am not questioning anyone just stating that I may not be the person to put the kind of work in these guys that they for sure require. I agree that without the dark egg they would be "just chickens". I do get excited when I get that dark egg though it is pretty cool