Quote:
It really depends on what your goal is. Do you just want dark eggs, and are happy with the egg color you have? Then go ahead.
Do you want to breed toward the (proposed) standard of perfection? Your rooster has a squirrel's tail, and as you said ...... way to much color on the chest (should be 10% or less, I have been told).
I wouldn't use him, but that's just me. Actually, I have had
several that looked just like that (some looked much much worse)! I culled them all, and just keep trying! I have had about 25 BCMarans roosters (ummm, maybe even more). I have kept only one. He is a roo I hatched from one of Wynette's bonus eggs that she sent me when I bought Jersey Giant eggs from her. I hatched 3 BCMs from her. 2 pullets and a roo. He is really a great guy. We will likely always keep him around here because we all love him!
https://www.backyardchickens.com/forum/uploads/31282_july_10_2010_pic_050.jpg
Kathy~
I thought you only hatched out ugly boys???????
He is a keeper!
Havi~
He does have a nice comb, good eye color and I do like his stance, but I would not use him for breeding either. TOO much red. But honestly what he looks like does not matter if you are only going to breed for egg color like Kathy stated above.