I get Golden Comets from Cackle, and I have done very well with them. No deaths, all good healthy birdies.
This may be the last time, as my plan is to breed my own sex links. FaerieSpuns!
Also I got some wonderful little lemon blue Modern Game Bird Banties from Ideal, along with some black Sex Links, and these banties did great. That was the only place I could find them, and so next year I will breed some of them for myself, also. I have not built their tiny coop yet.
But anyway, even though Ideal is in Texas, which is a lONG way from WV, the tiny banties still came just fine.
I have not gotten anything from McMurray for years, just because I usually try to go with the hatchery that has exactly what I want, and I also look carefully at prices, but in general, my birds from hatcheries have done well.
I had one batch several years ago that the PO sent to the wrong place, oddly, and they did not do well, AND they all got killed by a raccoon, not the hatchery's fault, of course, but they were poor doers from the start, but truly I believe this is the exception.
Catherine