Willawong Hill
Songster
Hi @jeberhard you're welcome to join other working on this project colour here https://www.backyardchickens.com/threads/mille-fleur-bantam-cochin-spangled-pekin-project.1480257/ it's really hard to tell who will end up with the best colouring until they're a year or so old. I'd be inclined to go with the boy with less black if you say your pullet is very dark but if you can spare a bit more time to let them grow that would be good as I think the other boy has a nicer comb.