Millie breeders, which roo would you keep?!?!?!

[Tsagirl]

I am at a total debate on which roo to keep. The first 4 pictures are from the new rooster I just rec'd from a breeder and the other 4-5pics are from my rooster which I got from a breeder, but has no beard. There foot feathering looks good, I am just wondering what you guys think?!?!?! Comb, confirmation?!??!?!?! Who would you pick to go to shows and be part of the breeding program? They are both really sweet.

http://picasaweb.google.com/tsableisch/WhichRoo#


Please look and let me know what you think. I need to know by tomorrow?

I love your opinions and that is why I love BYC!!

Tsa

 

[joza2210]

The first 4 pictures of that roo i think is the nicest one ...
The beards do matter and he also has nice feet feathers

 

[Tsagirl]

Thank you for your comments, its just so hard to tell when I am just starting the breeding. I wish that it would be easier. I see now that the 2nd roo hardly has any saddle feathers either. Hmmm I wonder if that is a genetic problem and he has not even grown his beard and he is over a year. Hmmmmmmm....

Anybody else?!?!?!

 

[Tsagirl]

anyone???

 

[drumstick diva]

I pick No. 1

 

[Celtic Hill]

Number two by far has a stronger comb and a more correct color pattern in my opinion. A good place to post the pics would be at the duccle breeders database. https://www.backyardchickens.com/forum/viewtopic.php?id=326626