dredging up an old thread, but you ladies look like you'll know the answers
. I get raw whole milk through a local coop, where I purchased a share of the cow in exchange for 1gal/week of her delicious milk (illegal to 'sell' raw milk here too, so I pay for her care, not for her milk
). I get about 1/2 pint of cream each week, which I scoop off the top of the milk when it's settled for a day or so. Made butter with about a cup of the milk a few weeks ago using a mason jar & shaking for 1/2 hour, worked swell. I did it again 2 weeks ago, but with the whole 1/2 pint. I shook
forever but it wasn't turning to butter & I had something to do, so put it in the fridge, came back to it the next day & figured I'd try some more, still didn't turn to butter, same thing the next day. I knew at the time that putting it down would probably change the logistics of the butter making process, obviously it can't be made that way, I had to throw the batch out. So today I set out knowing I would have a long haul of shaking. I sat down to watch a Scooby Doo movie with my daughter & shook away... through the entire movie, 1 1/2 hours!! Read online about doing it in a mixer so I throw it in the KitchenAid, whip on medium/high to high setting for 20 minutes & it wouldn't turn to butter! I swear it would go from stiff peaks to almost butter (but still obviously not, way to airy, the recipe I saw called this the 'chunky' phase, said the buttermilk should pour out any second), back to stiff peaks, back to chuncky, back to stiff peaks. I finally gave up and now have a bunch of whipped cream. Are there circumstances that the cream won't turn to butter? I know certain times of year make better butter than others, but I didn't think it ever wouldn't turn to butter. Can it be
over churned? HELP! I'm outta butter and with all this cream I keep getting I don't want to go buy it