I've recently had some phone and e-mail discussions with a Muscovy researcher in Texas and with Dr. George Allen at FWS.
Dr. Allen indicated that he is inclined to revise the rules in line with the spirit and intent of the following:
Amend 21.14 Permit exceptions for captive-bred migratory waterfowl other than mallard ducks to include the following:
Domestic Muscovy ducks have a long history of domestication and have long been raised as livestock both in the United States and around the world. Muscovy ducks that are owned as livestock (for the production of meat, eggs, or breeding stock), pets, or for exhibition shall be considered domestic Muscovy ducks.
No migratory bird permit(s) shall be required to possess, propagate, or sell (as live birds, meat, or eggs) domestic Muscovy ducks.
The intentional release of domestic Muscovy ducks to the wild shall be prohibited.
You may not take Muscovy ducks or their eggs from the wild , unless such taking is provided for elsewhere in this subchapter.
Do not place any additional restrictions on domestic Muscovy ducks other than items 2-4 above.
Keep 21.54 Control order for muscovy ducks in the United States in effect without revision. It seems important that landowners, and Federal, State, Tribal and local wildlife management agencies be able to control feral populations of Muscovy ducks in areas where they are not native without a depredation permit.
I think these are win-win points that help Dr. Allen achieve his objectives, while allowing us to continue to raise Muscovies without a Federal permit, thus protecting one's right to farm.
For a sample letter to send to Dr. Allen visit:
http://muscovyban.blogspot.com/2010/04/rule-by-u-s-fish-and-wildlife-service.html
Mac_