Well I guess I am the only odd ball. I had problems with the reds like you. I went to the comets and they were worse, they killed 3 of my girls. Most of them are bald out there to or bleeding half the time, it gets worse in the winter for me because I cant free range them as much, they don't seem to like the snow and head for the road, (not that I care at this point) but my other girls follow. I know my run and coop is big enough I actually made things too big, just in case I got more chickens the space would already be there. I have hung cabbage and everything, once that is gone, it is back to the picking and it doesn't seem to take them long to finish anything, they are also pigs!
I know others have had luck, maybe it depends on where you get them, I have no idea. I know this year they are getting replaced with calm birds, I can't take this no more I lost some of my favorite girls.