The only thing I can count on mine to do is lay in the coop. They have 7 nests for 14 hens (just the way things ended up) including varying sizes and privacy / darkness, so it's not like they have no choices. Yesterday all the eggs were in 2 nests, but during a typical week I always find some in a corner or even out on the coop floor. I gave up fighting it a long time ago; I just freshen the shavings, keep a few golf balls around, and collect them where I find them. I have had a hen lay and collect eggs outside the coop, twice as I recall, but they were broodies. Lately the broodies just move them around in the coop.