New and need help sorting my chicks.

[WanderingGarden]

I got these from a hatchery almost 5 weeks ago and need help sorting which is which...

I am hoping someone can help me with chick identification...

First photo is my Barnevelder - does the black upright tail at 5 weeks indicate a roo?

Am I right that these are all roosters? I am guessing based on large combs, color of combs for 2 of them, and small tale for age (they did not really have tails at 3 weeks and the rest did). I think the white one is my white rock?

Not sure about our mystery chick, partridge rock, or 2 Ameraucanas:

Melissa has green legs so I thought she would be Ameraucana, but she has no beard or tufts appearing...

Coon is the top roo in the rooster picture and in this photo - seems to have white on the edges of his feathers and has been slowest to develop, although he has large feet - I am guessing (a Silver Penciled Rock and) the mystery chick? Until two days ago he was almost completely a greyish fluff and had rings around his eyes. He started with brown chipmunk stripes like John and Taco.

This is Taco and I was guessing Partridge Rock? (My bottom chick of the three possible roosters, also)

This is John and I was guessing she is the other Ameraucana because her darker feet have a greenish cast to them?

None of the chicks have beards or muffs at all yet so I am feeling a little baffled. My husband says no roosters and 2 are already pretty aggressive with the rest of the hens so I am doing my best to figure them all out and enjoying every minute with them!

 

[JedJackson]

Which hatchery did they come from? That would help us narrow it down, since we can look at their breed list and go from there.

 

[WanderingGarden]

Murray McMurray. I know what breeds I ordered except my one mystery chick, I am just not sure which chick is which breed. Thanks for helping me figure it out!

 

[WanderingGarden]

Which hatchery did they come from? That would help us narrow it down, since we can look at their breed list and go from there.

Thanks for taking a look at them. I have more pictures of them on Instagram at different ages. The ones I am not sure of their breed are the ones I got from Murray McMurray.

 

[Crazy for Chickens!]

Well, your "ameraucanas" are actually Easter Eggers. Unless they are labeled as a specific color, that's what they are.
EEs can be any color, and sometimes don't have muffs/beard, like yours, in is case. They can lay green, blue, or pink eggs. I agree that your white one and the last on are your girls.

You are correct on the other breeds.
I see some cockerels.