YAY this is the fun part!
I love colorful eggs and pretty hens so listed in no particular order would be *my* ideal small flock
Brown and dark brown layers:
*Marans (I’m partial to blue birchen) they lay dark chocolate eggs, are beautiful and friendly hens.
*Beilefelders lay an abundance of large brown eggs with speckles, are friendly.
*I also love barnevelders (also brown eggs) especially the ones from greenfire farms. Beautiful!
White or tinted:
*55 flower hen lay an abundance of huge white almost round eggs.
*Smaaland lay tinted eggs ~ I think she is the sweetest hen I’ve ever had.
Colored eggs:
*Cream legbar usually lay sky blue eggs but could be green. Pretty cute with a funny crest on their heads. Can be flighty but mine were sweet.
*Isbar lay moss green eggs with green flecks.
*Lavender Orpington. Very sweet and lay pinkish to brownish eggs.
Greenfire farms is in Florida and has almost all of these breeds and I think they have great stock of pretty interesting breeds. Some of the breeds I mentioned are auto-sexing (meaning you can tell the sex at birth by the color pattern of the chicks down) but greenfire doesn’t vent sex so you take the chance of having boys. I’d also look at my pet chicken if you don’t want to deal with boys since they will vent sex the non autosexing breeds. Or what I’d do is get the rarer breeds from greenfire (and rehome a few boys) and get the rest from my pet chicken for the more “normal” breeds.
Keep us posted on what you get. There are so many really fun breeds and I love seeing what people decide!