What does the source of the seeds that a crop is raised from have to do with whether it is organic or Genetically Modified? Every food and feed stuff that you buy and eat or that you buy and feed to your chickens has been, or will be sprayed dusted, or treated at one time or the other with some pretty nasty chemicals. That is if you are a grasshopper, cutworm, or aphid. Think about it, if this wasn't true then there would not be any organic food on the shelves at the grocery store. "Organic" does not mean pesticide free but instead means that all (well most of) the pesticides employed to grow "organic" food
are the older more dangerous generation of pesticides. Thank of these pesticides like they were the same old poisons that Rachael Carson was so concerned about. Most of this generation of pesticides was first isolated from other plants that demonstrated resistance to insect pests and then mass produced.
If not the largest, Monsanto is ONE of the largest providers of these so called "organic" pesticides. Monsanto does not want to stop selling pesticides to both camps in the "organic" food fight. They make money from both camps. The next big thing in the GMO seed industry is to improve the yields of GM crops. This is why Monsanto is buying out other seed companies. It is to gain access to their patented crop verities that may have over 100 years of research behind them. This and this alone is why some GM crops have lower yields than their conventional competitors. Monsanto is as big a victim of conventional seed companies as the eat "organic" or die crowd says that Monsanto is a conspiracy to ruin small farmers.
Now this bit of trivia from the halls of the evil seed empire. Not only did Monsanto refuse to renew their patent on RoundUp herbicide about 10 years ago, but they allowed their US patent on RoundUp Ready Soy-Beans to expire. I am sure that all the "organic" activist will sing Monsanto's praises from the highest mountain top. Starting this year all the "organic" soy-bean farmers in America can plant RoundUp ready soybeans and save the seeds from their heritage glyphosate resistant legumes and replant them year after year to their hearts content without paying Monsanto a penny for the privilege or having a GMO paper trail leading back to Monsanto to hide.
Sing their praises? No. Transgenic crops are not allowed in organic. Furthermore the GE traits are dominant. Step around to the other side of the fence for a minute. Certified organic farmers have a slew of restrictions and constant monitoring just to be able to label their products organic. It takes 3 years of land prep ahead of time, land buffers are required, soil testing, feedstock (materials to be composted) must all be kept track of and tested, composting is much more closely regulated, it goes on and on. They can use non-organic seeds if organic is not available.. but still no GMO. There's a lovely long list of prohibited substances- yes, they can use some biological treatments.
Funny you should mention "old poisons".. they are making a comeback in industrial ag. Glyphosate isn't effective as so many weeds have developed resistances, so it is being mixed with other herbicides by farmers (most of which don't exactly hold a chemistry background.) Testing on safety isn't as diligent as you would think- in any part of it (regarding GMO consumption or even the 'cides- many of which have been on the market for decades. As long as certain cancers remain a quirky coincidence to those exposed vs verified carcinogen or immune system inhibitor- they're not liable.)
GM tech isn't 100 years old. It's half that. You're talking about a major powerhouse company on a global scale that is incredibly diversified. Earlier this year DuPont & Monsanto buried the hatchet and have now teamed up with their seed technologies. Together- that's 2/3rds of the total corn & soy seed market. Now have you ever planted corn? Let me give you an idea where the problem comes up- corn is a relative to grass and like grass it is wind pollinated. In bloom, the pollen is released by the millions everyday for about 2 weeks and is able to ride a light breeze up to 2 miles away. Do you know what everyone in a 2 mile radius is growing? There aren't any constraints on conventional farmers to prevent cross contamination- that burden is on organic producers. Then situations arise like in Oregon when an unapproved Monsanto GMO wheat shows up in a farmer's field- over 10 years after it was legally planted.
Civilization came about on the backs of organic farmers. Crop diversity didn't start in a lab- it started with common people growing food for their families. While Golden rice is brandished as a major accomplishment- realize there's thousands of years of selective breeding to get it where it is now. It originated from a weedy plant with only a few kernels and it shattered easily. There are thousands of different varieties of tomatoes, corn, peppers, beans, flowers, etc. of which a vast majority- started in someone's garden. Many times diseases have hit crops- and natural resistances were utilized. That is possible with diversity. When you have dominant genetics that are not naturally found in that species (then slap on it patent laws).. that's obliterating diversity.
If you wish to consume/support GMO- that is your choice. Respect those who opt to support organic. Their support keeps diversity possible (something farmers who wish to not grow GMO are having trouble with as sourcing seed is an issue. Try looking into the plight of organic seed producers.) Yes- the major corporations are dabbling in that as well. Same company that poisoned neighborhoods with PCB. Same one that lied about safety to avoid accountability. Same one that's primary drive is monetary "We can't afford to lose one more dollar of business" and has profits in the billions. Same one that has been caught falsifying data in their studies.. even went as far as claiming dioxin was not carcinogenic. These companies are allowed to police themselves- and have lobbyists galore.
Like I said- if you want to go further into this.. I will happily join the discussion. This thread is Weeflock's and they are looking into non-gmo feeds. (apologies for the tangent/ long response.)