Thanks StarMe and FVRM. These are my first chickens and maybe I'm not really sure how to expect the roosters to act. I'm comfortable and confident around animals and (in my head anyway!) don't come across as timid or fearful, but I've had a hell of a time with my roos. We started off with 27 birds- 4...oops, that's a 5th! roosters and 22 hens. Five roosters were WAY too many and fighting too much, so the Welsummer roo and a silver laced polish were dinner. They went first because both of them had a go at me multiple times too. Now I've got this giant Austra roo going at me and occasionally the other little oops SLP roo. Our easter egger boy is very stand-off-ish, but has never shown the slightest inclination to bother me, and in fact seems to intercept the other two roos when they start to get their hackles up at me. All the birds were day-olds from a hatchery and have been hand raised, so I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong. It seems unlikely that all but 1 rooster would be aggressive. Do I cull all but that one? Sigh. Maybe I'll figure it out one day. That's why the "gentle" bielefelder sounds wonderful! But with DoubleA's info, it sounds like that might not be the solution I want either. Thanks for the input, everyone!!!
Rabyn
Generally, hatcheries breed for production first, not temperament. You can still get nice friendly chickens from hatchery stock but there will be mean ones too. It's best to get them from someone that has been breeding for good temperament for at least a few generations, regardless of breed.