Official BYC Poll: What Do You Do With Broody Hens?

What do you do with broody hens?

  • Leave them without eggs until they stop

    Votes: 48 26.2%
  • Take them out every day

    Votes: 59 32.2%
  • Break them

    Votes: 64 35.0%
  • Give them eggs within the flock

    Votes: 60 32.8%
  • Separate them and give them eggs

    Votes: 47 25.7%
  • Other (elaborate in a reply below)

    Votes: 24 13.1%

  • Total voters
    183
Broodies get to set on 8-10 eggs. I had three setting on eggs within 2-3 days of each other this year. I thought it was going to be a battle..... but they all adopted each other's chicks. I had 18 chicks using one hen for a jungle gym while the host to half the horde was across the field at her favorite dust bath. 20 minutes later she came back and half the horde scrambled back under her.

Good times. 26 chicks all at once was a bit much though.

EDIT: Realized I didn't answer the poll. I keep them in the flock doing chicken things. Figure they have more experience being chickens than I do.
 
Last edited:
I have a Barnvelder, Spice, who goes broody about once a month if she doesn't have chicks. Sometimes I break her. I have a dog crate in the run so she's not isolated, but it can take a week to break her! I let her sit a couple of times a year. She currently has 2 babies that are 8 weeks old. She will usually take care of them for 10 to 12 weeks. When I do get an egg from her it's beautiful! I'm usually able to sell the ones I don't want to keep.
 
I have a Barnvelder, Spice, who goes broody about once a month if she doesn't have chicks. Sometimes I break her. I have a dog crate in the run so she's not isolated, but it can take a week to break her! I let her sit a couple of times a year. She currently has 2 babies that are 8 weeks old. She will usually take care of them for 10 to 12 weeks. When I do get an egg from her it's beautiful! I'm usually able to sell the ones I don't want to keep.
I have a Barnevelder that goes broody often, too, and she’s not content with raising just one batch per year - she keeps wanting more! 😄 I didn’t expect this. I’d read that this breed isn’t prone to broodiness.
 
Mostly I allow them to brood chicks but when I want to break a broody I use broody jail for 3 days, 3 nights - a wire bottom cage in the main coop at night and outside during the day so still within the flock.
I allow them to brood within the flock unless there is an issue then I will seperate.
I only have Silkies so lots of broody mummas each year 😂 currently 3 are broody, 2 are raising 3 chicks each and another is sitting on 8 eggs. My 9.5 year old started laying again so she may go broody in a few weeks too.
I do like to eat eggs though so I try to have just one or 2 brood at a time! It's many months before I get eggs from a broody -3 wks to hatch plus around 12 wks raising them. Nowonder my old hen is still laying because she broods so often 😂
IMG_20211112_112141.jpg

I nearly lost one of the chicks the other day to a black bird, crow I think, swooped down but mumma Puff attacked and I ran to help. Lucky all are ok 😥 They all stayed in the enclosed run area the rest of that day.
IMG_20211116_111245.jpg
 
I have one that gets this way every so often. Knocking her off the nesting box a few times typically stops this behavior. Sometimes I have to go out at night and do this too. A time or two sleeping on the floor and she stops the broods real fast. One time I did have to put her in her own cage and let her do a solo sabbatical for about a week to stop the behavior.

Hopefully we don't have to deal with this anymore because it IS annoying. She gets to the point where the other girls will try to go in there to lay and she's harrassing them, and then squabbles happen when she wants to grab the egg the moment it falls out the others pooper and roll it under her.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom