- Thread starter
- #241
Quote:
I am curious as to why there is a need to "classify" further than function? It appears from these that this is an attempt to distinguish an age to a breed. I'm not certain it is necessary for a "Classification" The age of the breed has no bearing on anything other than history.
There is already a class system that distinguishes origin, which only serves to partition breeds. The only functional classifications are for purpose. Ornamental, egg, meat, and dual purpose. These are quantifiable by standard and functional. Any other classification or partition would only serve the market or the show ring.
It seems to me that if we as the keepers of livestock would put more emphasis on the purpose of the animal and less on vanity, nature would help us maintain better breeds.
Just my humble opinion.
Already there is a classification system which you didn't mention (actually 2 systems): APA large fowl system and the Bantam system based on combs and legs.
You forgot Games.
My reasoning was because of history and the age of a breed. The age of a breed is important to many of us who are preservationist.
Thanks for the question. I'm sure I didn't answer to anyones satisfaction though.
I am curious as to why there is a need to "classify" further than function? It appears from these that this is an attempt to distinguish an age to a breed. I'm not certain it is necessary for a "Classification" The age of the breed has no bearing on anything other than history.
There is already a class system that distinguishes origin, which only serves to partition breeds. The only functional classifications are for purpose. Ornamental, egg, meat, and dual purpose. These are quantifiable by standard and functional. Any other classification or partition would only serve the market or the show ring.
It seems to me that if we as the keepers of livestock would put more emphasis on the purpose of the animal and less on vanity, nature would help us maintain better breeds.
Just my humble opinion.
Already there is a classification system which you didn't mention (actually 2 systems): APA large fowl system and the Bantam system based on combs and legs.
You forgot Games.
My reasoning was because of history and the age of a breed. The age of a breed is important to many of us who are preservationist.
Thanks for the question. I'm sure I didn't answer to anyones satisfaction though.