I know. That's why it's one of my theories. LOL The question for this thread (until I can catch one of the three in the nest boxes), do the eggs that start being laid by a former broody, look as small as a pullet just beginning to lay? If she resumes egg laying, do they go back to normal size from the get-go? If they do, then I'll eliminate her as the small egg layer and look to the EE pullet being a brown egg layer or the AustraWhite not really being a cockerel. I don't know, maybe I just have to go sit in the coop all day and take note of who goes into the nest boxes and how long they are there, and what egg they leave.Easter eggers can lay brown - especially pinky-brown

My question to the group...when a broody is done raising chicks, I know they'll take a week or two before they start laying again. My question is will her eggs look like new pullet eggs? The reason I ask is because I have 15 chickens. Today, I got 13 eggs. I have 6 new chickens but I think one is a cockerel, and I got 6 small eggs. I am trying to figure out if the suspected cockerel is really a pullet after all or if the year old broody hen is laying already. (The other theory is that one of my Easter Egger pullets isn't laying blue eggs but brown.)
I got a "fart" egg last week - it was smaller than a pullet or bantam egg, dark dark brown shell (I don't have hens that lay that dark normally) and it had no yolk. That may have been her first egg since going broody. Since then I've been getting 3 brown small eggs. These new eggs are either 1) her eggs, 2) EE laying non blue or green eggs, or 3) cockerel really is pullet.
CG