Opinions wanted!! Broody hen integrated or separated?

I know there are multiple opinions on this subject, but I want to hear them all!

I am putting fertilized eggs under my 7-day broody hen on Wednesday. She is already a mean girl. THE mean girl (white French marans). She is in the corner of the henhouse (elevated 3 feet off the ground). I have 5 other hens. They have stopped laying eggs anywhere near her.

I want to let her raise her babies fully integrated. It will take a heck of a lot of work to build anything for her to separate her, but I can do it if I HAVE to for success. I’m giving her -not cheap- jubilee Orpington eggs, so I am not willing to throw all caution to the wind. I want to hear your risk assessments before I do this.

Alright guys, I would love to hear your thoughts.
Just a word of caution....watch her closely when they start to hatch. We did the same thing with a first time broody...bought hatching eggs. She did great until they started hatching and then she killed them! We were able to save 2 and get them in a brooder before she killed them too. Not sure what she was thinking....I think she saw the new chicks as intruders and was trying to protect her eggs.
 
I know there are multiple opinions on this subject, but I want to hear them all!

I am putting fertilized eggs under my 7-day broody hen on Wednesday. She is already a mean girl. THE mean girl (white French marans). She is in the corner of the henhouse (elevated 3 feet off the ground). I have 5 other hens. They have stopped laying eggs anywhere near her.

I want to let her raise her babies fully integrated. It will take a heck of a lot of work to build anything for her to separate her, but I can do it if I HAVE to for success. I’m giving her -not cheap- jubilee Orpington eggs, so I am not willing to throw all caution to the wind. I want to hear your risk assessments before I do this.

Alright guys, I would love to hear your thoughts.
I did what you are doing. I also had six hens. I put fertile eggs under my broody hen. I kept her integrated. She was one of my meek chickens; but, I have to say, my hens have never been aggressive toward each other. My only problem was she decided to go broody in the favorite nest box, so the first day or so the other chickens kept trying to crowd in the box with her and a couple of eggs got broken. I moved her to another box and put a short curtain in front of the opening to give her some privacy. This took care of the problem. Other than that, I made no other changes. Once the chicks hatched, she became very protective of them. I was surprised with this behavior based on how timid she was prior to becoming a mama. I saw no signs of aggression by the other hens toward the chicks. In fact, they seemed to simply ignore them. The hen kept her chicks and herself separated from the rest of the group until the chicks were almost as big as her. Then, literally, one day, she simply walked away from them and went back to the flock. She never interacted with the chicks again.

One word of warning. I lost two chicks to predation the first two days after hatching (one per day) before I figured out it was a squirrel. It was slipping through the chain-link of the run and going into the coop to prey upon the chicks (dirty bugger).

I also candled (flashlight and toilet paper tube) the eggs to verify they were fertile and developing. I removed any eggs that weren't viable.

Sorry this is so long. I'm excited for you. Enjoy the process. For me, it was very amazing and interesting to behold.
 
I did what you are doing. I also had six hens. I put fertile eggs under my broody hen. I kept her integrated. She was one of my meek chickens; but, I have to say, my hens have never been aggressive toward each other. My only problem was she decided to go broody in the favorite nest box, so the first day or so the other chickens kept trying to crowd in the box with her and a couple of eggs got broken. I moved her to another box and put a short curtain in front of the opening to give her some privacy. This took care of the problem. Other than that, I made no other changes. Once the chicks hatched, she became very protective of them. I was surprised with this behavior based on how timid she was prior to becoming a mama. I saw no signs of aggression by the other hens toward the chicks. In fact, they seemed to simply ignore them. The hen kept her chicks and herself separated from the rest of the group until the chicks were almost as big as her. Then, literally, one day, she simply walked away from them and went back to the flock. She never interacted with the chicks again.

One word of warning. I lost two chicks to predation the first two days after hatching (one per day) before I figured out it was a squirrel. It was slipping through the chain-link of the run and going into the coop to prey upon the chicks (dirty bugger).

I also candled (flashlight and toilet paper tube) the eggs to verify they were fertile and developing. I removed any eggs that weren't viable.

Sorry this is so long. I'm excited for you. Enjoy the process. For me, it was very amazing and interesting to behold.
Awesome info thank you! I hope this goes that well. I am sorry about your lost chicks :(
 
Just a word of caution....watch her closely when they start to hatch. We did the same thing with a first time broody...bought hatching eggs. She did great until they started hatching and then she killed them! We were able to save 2 and get them in a brooder before she killed them too. Not sure what she was thinking....I think she saw the new chicks as intruders and was trying to protect her eggs.
Oh goodness. Thank you for the tip. I will be on the lookout
 
I know there are multiple opinions on this subject, but I want to hear them all!

I am putting fertilized eggs under my 7-day broody hen on Wednesday. She is already a mean girl. THE mean girl (white French marans). She is in the corner of the henhouse (elevated 3 feet off the ground). I have 5 other hens. They have stopped laying eggs anywhere near her.

I want to let her raise her babies fully integrated. It will take a heck of a lot of work to build anything for her to separate her, but I can do it if I HAVE to for success. I’m giving her -not cheap- jubilee Orpington eggs, so I am not willing to throw all caution to the wind. I want to hear your risk assessments before I do this.

Alright guys, I would love to hear your thoughts.
I have 2 broody hens, one is a black maran and one is a Russian Orloff. we ordered more Orloff eggs for them to sit on, they started hatching on 6/19/2020- one so far and today it moved in the house to a heat lamp as the Orloff hen kept letting it out of the nest and in Wyoming, our mornings are still cool. I have 7 more to hatch hopefully! My other 8 hens are evil and I feared one of them would hurt the little. Hopefully when it gets bigger I will try introducing it back to them so I wish you and your clan great happy success.
 
I know there are multiple opinions on this subject, but I want to hear them all!

I am putting fertilized eggs under my 7-day broody hen on Wednesday. She is already a mean girl. THE mean girl (white French marans). She is in the corner of the henhouse (elevated 3 feet off the ground). I have 5 other hens. They have stopped laying eggs anywhere near her.

I want to let her raise her babies fully integrated. It will take a heck of a lot of work to build anything for her to separate her, but I can do it if I HAVE to for success. I’m giving her -not cheap- jubilee Orpington eggs, so I am not willing to throw all caution to the wind. I want to hear your risk assessments before I do this.

Alright guys, I would love to hear your thoughts.
You don't have to build anything. Get one of those inexpensive wire dog crates--bigger than small... smaller than huge. (I bought a small one for hospital lodging at Walmart.) You can make some kind of privacy covering if you need to, but don't make it stuffy esp as it's summer.

Put it in the coop where she's sitting now, or as near as you can. Stick some bedding in there, some food and water, and put her in with some fake eggs to make sure she doesn't freak out and damage your pricey eggs. If you need to, you can start them in the incubator (which you ought to have, just in case, anyway) and give them to her at night once you decide she has settled in.

If you decide you want a designated broody coop, here's one I made.
74111AE4-A633-45BE-8FE9-C6E1C3163CA6.jpeg
BC3C8E33-B63E-466E-955B-49DE09EFD7A9.jpeg
35943134-F137-47F3-B620-35B1E29F8601.jpeg
069BC1B7-4F31-4948-A212-5ACF4E913252.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • 644884CF-04DC-4C68-8BEF-22EAAEEF4CE0.jpeg
    644884CF-04DC-4C68-8BEF-22EAAEEF4CE0.jpeg
    1.1 MB · Views: 2
You don't have to build anything. Get one of those inexpensive wire dog crates--bigger than small... smaller than huge. (I bought a small one for hospital lodging at Walmart.) You can make some kind of privacy covering if you need to, but don't make it stuffy esp as it's summer.

Put it in the coop where she's sitting now, or as near as you can. Stick some bedding in there, some food and water, and put her in with some fake eggs to make sure she doesn't freak out and damage your pricey eggs. If you need to, you can start them in the incubator (which you ought to have, just in case, anyway) and give them to her at night once you decide she has settled in.

If you decide you want a designated broody coop, here's one I made.
View attachment 2206817View attachment 2206818View attachment 2206822View attachment 2206823
That’s a cute little coop! Since this is the only time I’m ever planning on doing this I am not planning to build. I have a dog crate but unfortunately we have mink. So they can get into anything like that. I’m thinking if we have issues to wrap the crate in hardware cloth.
 
If you have mink, I'd wrap the crate preemptively. It's still a lot easier and faster than building from scratch. Having a private space prevents other hens from laying in the nest while mama is taking a break and gives the new little family a few days of privacy until mama (or you) decide the littles are ready to go out.
 
Update! We are on day 16 now. All is well. lost one egg to a small crack last week. I candled all of them that I could get my hands on last night and 3/4 were perfect. There are 9 total but momma began to bite sooo hard - and twist my skin!! So I gave up.
One buff Orpington will try to babysit while momma leaves the nest to bathe but I kick her off and lock her out.
Fingers still crossed for a happy ending. I am remaining very vigilant for trouble.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom