Picky chicken laying soft eggs

You have a few different things going on. If she is the only one doing this, you have a hen problem. If many other flock members are doing it, you may have a flock problem. If she‘s the only one laying, you may not be able to tell which you have yet.

First, stop feeding scratch totally. Cut it out 100% and see if that helps. Layer has extra calcium in it, usually all the calcium a hen needs for her egg shells if that is all she eats. A vast majority of chickens have the instinct to eat the oyster shell if they need the calcium, but that’s most chickens, not all.

Not all hens process the calcium they do eat the same either. A whole lot of what calcium they do eat doesn’t get absorbed and used by the hen but passes straight on through to the poop. Different hens absorb different amounts.

Yours has just started to lay. Sometimes it takes a week or two for them to work out all the kinks in their internal egg making factory. I would give her a little more time before I decided she was not going to straighten out.

Chickens will probably have a preference for certain foods. They normally like scratch better than chicken feed. They also can have a preference for pellets or crumbles. They can be different. Mine prefer pellets over crumbles, but many people have the opposite. I’ve never had a chicken starve herself to death of food is available, but think of it as some kids prefer candy to fresh vegetables if you give them the choice. I’ve had chickens swallow a plum pit and mice are a fairly regular part of their diet when I have the traps set. I seriously doubt the size of those pellets present a danger to 6 month old chickens. If it did, pellets would not be used universally for chickens that age.

When you get two eggs the same day, it means her internal egg making factory screwed up. She released two yolks instead of one. When she releases two at once you often get a double yolked egg. If they are spaced out a bit, you get two separate eggs the same day. The hen’s shell gland normally only makes a certain amount of shell material, enough for one normal egg a day. As I said before, some process it differently. If you get a tiny egg, the shell may be really thick because the hen produced enough shell material for a larger egg. If she lays a double yolked egg or two a day, those can be pretty thin compared to a regular sized egg. It’s fairly normal that the second one is really thin or even soft shelled.

What causes a hen to release two yolks? With some it is genetic. Their internal egg making factory just doesn’t work right. Pullets just starting out sometimes need to work the kinks out. Double yolked eggs or other problems are fairly common when a pullet just starts to lay. As complex as that egg making system is what is amazing to me is how many get it right to start with. Feeding a high amount of protein can make this problem worse if she has a tendency toward this.

So I suggest feeding the pellets only with oyster shell offered on the side. If you feel the need, you can crack the pellets for her but don’t take them to a powder. The different nutrients can separate and form layers in the feed so she might not get a balanced although the feed contains everything she needs. Give her time to see if she straightens up.

Good luck!