Maybe it´s just your gander, then. If you got another pair it may not be the same. Why would two pairs be hassle? I´m not knocking, I just don´t know what your set-up is, and I find Pilgrims are easy to keep a few pairs. They squabble the tiniest bit, get it sorted, and then get on with it. But of course, it´s down to you. I´ve just related what I´ve found to be the case here.Out of the 13 eggs in Nimbo's nest this year 5 of the eggs were duds apparently from day one. When I cracked them they were liquid, no development at all. I was told one or two out of the 6 I sold hatched in an incubator and the first egg she laid was fertile. So total, its half that were fertile from all the eggs she laid.
I have the pen next to my room window so I can hear them when they are locked up and they spent most of the breeding season in the front yard because the grass there was growing so well. I really should have seen or heard something more then I did.
I am still pondering how my boy Cirrus would do. I really would like to get another girl if its doable. Eventually I could get another gander if the trio didn't work. Preferably though if he couldn't handle another girl I would stick with what I have. Having one pair is better for my set up then two pairs. I can do two pairs, its just a hassle.
![big_smile.png](https://www.backyardchickens.com/styles/byc-smilies/big_smile.png)