Quote: I'd sort of like to hear that one, too, having raised blacks from BBS lines in three different breeds, Orps, Ameraucanas and Rocks. If you look at a black Ameraucana, for instance, not knowing whether it came from two black parents who also had black parents, or a blue over a black parent, how on earth can you tell which line it came from?
ETA: I see we posted over each other. I have had blacks from blue breedings that had spectacular green sheen-have one black hen now whose green sheen can't be matched, IMO. I don't think that claim holds true down the line, I really don't. Could be in some cases, but overall, I can't see how it's an "always this way" case.