Quote:
What's the point in this though? All you're accomplishing is being dishonest.
I would never enter a Colombian Rock as a Light Sussex. Or vice versa. They look relatively the same.
I have a hard time believing an APA judge would tell you to enter a mutt bird as a pure NHR and try to compete.
He might have said that the two birds look similar, that the mutt Orp could possibly pass for a NHR...
But I can't understand why he would approve of entering and showing it as such.
It makes me question his credentials as a judge. Why would he knowingly allow such a thing to happen, let alone condone the behavior?
If one judge suggests it to see how close it is to the standard, then why not? Many people use breeds that are similar in order to bring in a new color or to improve type of some sort. If you enter a Columbian Rock as a Light Sussex you will get a DQ. The Columbian Rock should have yellow legs.
Now, if you're trying to better your Australorps by adding a black Orpington, why not put it in a show to see how close the F1 generation is going to look? Unlike dog shows, pedigrees are not necessary. Now, when a breeder sells his mixed mutts as a purebred bird to an unknowing purchaser, that is when there is an issue. But to show a mixed bird that meets a breed standard? I don't see an issue, especially if it's to see how your "line" compares to other birds that you are attempting to breed your birds to surpass.