We have a rule here - if we don't want a new one, we don't let the old one leave. Because there is always a chance once it leaves, it ain't coming back. If it's something we could part with, and wouldn't miss, then yeah, we'll loan it to you - if it makes it back, it does and if not no one is upset.
I USED to see an ad on criagslist for a plucker for rent - USED to being the key phrase....that was ages ago...haven't seen it in a long time...I'm guessing something happened...otherwise they'd still be trying to rent it...see what I'm saying?
I wouldn't take the chance with it. You never know when Tim the Toolman Taylor could get a hold of your plucker and turn it into a rocket launcher or something crazy...know what I mean? Could you see someone bringing it back and saying "I fixed your plucker, added more power! You can pluck an ELEPHANT now!"