Just coming to gush about my roo...
After two “failed” roosters, cockerels, really, that I got in my first ever batch of chicks, I now finally have a really good rooster.
I told the story of my first two here before, somewhere, just a recap:
I had ordered a male Welsummer chick and among the remaining 14 female chicks it eventually turned out I had a Buff Brahma cockerel, too. The Welsummer was all roo, developed much earlier than the Brahma and so became head of the flock at 4 months old. He was a bit of a brute with the girls, never titbided, never danced, but he was young and gorgeous and I thought things would get better. Then he started attacking me out if the blue and after trying to straighten him out for months and months I gave him up to a feed store (they rehome to a home or a stewpot, who knows).
So the Brahma became head roo (he had been completely content as part of the flock before, until the last couple of weeks) and the hens wouldn’t have it. They did not accept his lead and very few would let him mate with them. Things improved a tad over the next few weeks, but he was struggling so much staying on top of the hens when mating (he was huge them, especially the RIR and BRs) that in no time all my hens were bare backed. Too hot for saddles, plus they really didn’t like him. Bummer. Gave up this nice respectful clumsy roo to a good home with a hopefully more accepting flock that was free roaming all day - giving him stuff to do besides climbing the girls all day....
I knew I wanted another roo for my flock but was wary of getting another one that wouldn’t work out eventually. So I ordered 3 SFHs - after reading that the males are never human aggressive - 2 females and a male. I lost one female on the first day and ended up raising just those other two. Put them in a separate pen in the coop once they were old enough to be without heat and kept them there until they were 16 weeks. Quick integration (new hen had the roo as her best buddy and roo could stand up for himself and her, so it went really quite well), and all but one hen (former top hen and I believe maybe the one that started crowing after I introduced the cockerel) happy. That one hen fought the roo and eventually lost and the roo hated her and chased her away at any opportunity. Poor hen spent months mostly hiding in the nest boxes. I put up some blockades and made more hiding spots but it was not great (of course my favorite hen, so I didn’t want to give her away, either).
Finally after maybe 6 months I had them all free ranging one day and went to call them back to their pen. All went in but the roo - ??? I sent the dog to help and he stirred up my favorite hen, still out, too. Then we git to watch the roo expertly herd that hen into the pen: just the right amount of pressure, very calm, patient. She went in, he followed and they were reconciled from that day on. The oddest thing! Did he finally realize that she really was part of his flock?
Anyway, he turned out to be a great rooster. Sweet with the ladies, always gives them treats, calls them, guards them, doesn’t not mate excessively, does not destroy their feathers, takes no for an answer, is respectful of people (and this one was handled a lot as a youngster because I had to move them between pens twice a day, though not cuddled or played with) and gorgeous too. He even has a great crow! (My Brahma sounded like an old car horn)
So the gamble worked. I highly recommend a Swedish Flowerhen rooster!