Roosters won’t stop fighting

77horses

◊The Spontaneous Pullet!◊
15 Years
Aug 19, 2008
7,635
693
536
Maine
Hi all,
I have two silkie roosters who, as of late, cannot stop fighting. I hatched out three silkie eggs two summers ago- two ended up being roosters, one a hen. They were raised together and haven’t had any major problems the last two years other than the occasional squabble. There has always been one alpha between the two. They live with 4 hens in a spacious coop with an attached covered run. During the warmer months, they frequently free range so they have plenty of space there too. But during the colder months and especially once the snow arrives, they can no longer free range and are limited to the coop/run space. I think this might be contributing to the problem right now. I’ve also noticed the beta rooster has been getting more gutsy and challenging the alpha more frequently. But he always loses. Today it seems he really pushed his luck and has the injury to prove it. He has a small laceration on his head and some swelling. They’ve never caused each other an injury like this before.
What can I do? I don’t have a second space to separate them into. Culling one of them is not an option. I can’t try to give one away to someone because nobody wants a mean rooster unless they’re planning on eating them. Would adding more hens to the flock help? I do have more space in the coop for a bigger flock right now. That’s the only viable option I can think of.
 
two coops/two flocks
That would be something I could do if it weren’t during the winter months right now. There’s a lot of snow on the ground. It’s hard to build on. I suppose I could maybe find a used shed and create a makeshift coop until spring. I’m on a tight budget though, so I’m not sure what I’ll find. I’ll look.
 
4 hens is not enough. I’d get at least four more hens so you’ll have 8. Even with 2 coops, 2 hens cannot be enough. They’ll overbreed.
 
Hi all,
I have two silkie roosters who, as of late, cannot stop fighting. I hatched out three silkie eggs two summers ago- two ended up being roosters, one a hen. They were raised together and haven’t had any major problems the last two years other than the occasional squabble. There has always been one alpha between the two. They live with 4 hens in a spacious coop with an attached covered run. During the warmer months, they frequently free range so they have plenty of space there too. But during the colder months and especially once the snow arrives, they can no longer free range and are limited to the coop/run space. I think this might be contributing to the problem right now. I’ve also noticed the beta rooster has been getting more gutsy and challenging the alpha more frequently. But he always loses. Today it seems he really pushed his luck and has the injury to prove it. He has a small laceration on his head and some swelling. They’ve never caused each other an injury like this before.
What can I do? I don’t have a second space to separate them into. Culling one of them is not an option. I can’t try to give one away to someone because nobody wants a mean rooster unless they’re planning on eating them. Would adding more hens to the flock help? I do have more space in the coop for a bigger flock right now. That’s the only viable option I can think of.
David61 has given the best option imo.
More hens isn't likely to solve the problem. What will happpen is the new hens will show a preference for the senior/Alpha rooster while they all live together
The trick is to get the junior rooster to accept his new home. After that you could think about getting him a couple of hens if he can't attract the least favorite from the other group, but not before.
What can happen is the junior of the pair, once he has his own space will try to attract one of the least favoured from the other group. One of the reasons this works is the junior hen then becomes the top hen in the new group. It doesn't seem to matter if there arn't any other hens. She still gets the roosters full attention.
They will still fight even as two seperate groups if they free range. The roosters here all fight but in general it's not serious. Bloody combs and wattles is normal.
 
We have roosters and we found that the silkie seem to be the most aggressive with each together. Not very helpful info, but thought I would share! 😊😁
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom