I have kept chickens for years, and have had a lot of roosters. I have had two outstanding roosters out of all of them, one more that was pretty good. Chrome who was an expensive Biefelder and Captain, a mutt red, with a green tail, and Bye - who was never suppose to be kept as a flock master, ugly as sin, but simply checked off ALL of the other boxes:
- Good with people
- good with grandchildren
- calm
- ladies adored him
- broke up fights in his girls
- tidbitted to his girls
- kept his girls together
- good with chicks
- beautiful crow
- found and created nests for the hens (they never quite liked them, and he was good with that)
- good with predators warnings until the last one got him
I have had two roosters since Bye, snowman got aggressive. I have Longjohns - he is a middle of the road rooster - a nice bit of eye candy... but only checks part of the boxes.
Roosters are a crapshoot. I have a slim theory, that you get better roosters if they are raised in a multi-generational flock, under older birds and you do NOT MAKE A PET of him. This forum is filled with stories where the darling becomes the nightmare. They really are not good pet material.
If you cannot butcher a rooster, my advice would be to re-home him ASAP.
A lot of them do not work out, especially for inexperienced people. The traits that people think indicate that the rooster likes them, are often times pre-traits to not respecting people.
If the OP has
children under the age of 6 and especially if they share a yard with them, I strongly recommend letting the rooster go. Rooster are opportunist and will attack children first, often times in the face. It has often ruined the whole chicken experience.
On rereading the OP - and see their rooster is a year old and is doing fine, that is a good sign, but always be aware.
Mrs K